Presenter James Crawford takes us behind the scenes of the new series of Scotland from the Sky, exploring Scotland’s changing coastline, from amazing herring harbours to abandoned art deco swimming pools.
Our challenge with Series Two was where to go next. We wanted distinct themes for our three programmes. We knew the great strength the view from above has for storytelling and tracking change. It shows how places can evolve, but also how traces of what have gone before can remain, like ghostly imprints.
Our solution was to look at three key aspects of Scotland’s landscapes and history. Our countryside, our industry, and, for episode one, our coast.
James Crawford in the HES archives (Photo: BBC)
11,000 miles of stories
Scotland’s coastline is rugged and beautiful. It’s made up of over 11,000 miles of cliffs, crags, bays and inlets – each with their own stories. It’s where we built many of our first homes. It’s where we looked to for food and trade. It’s where we first watched the arrival of invaders, of refugees – of war. It has shaped who we are and how we live.
The remarkable Whaligoe Steps, just south of Wick, viewed by drone (Photo: BBC)
We began with a coastal feature that is almost entirely forgotten today – despite being something that we started building thousands of years ago, and which stayed in use even into the twentieth century. You can still find the remains of hundreds of them along Scotland’s coast. On the Moray Firth, there are traces every mile and a half. They are fish traps.
A lost way of life
From the ground, they just look like piles of stone or rubble. But get up in the air, and they appear – quite appropriately – like giant, man-made hooks. In the end, they were so effective (one account tells of some 2600 salmon taken from a trap near Thurso in a single day) that the construction of new traps was banned by parliament in the 1860s.
The remains of two fish traps on the Beauly Firth (Photo: BBC)
The result is that the remaining traps have become fragments of a lost way of life. From above their imprints still stay strong in the landscape. But time and tide will take their toll – and eventually, the last traps will disappear.
This is how it is with our coast. It’s littered with the traces of how we used to live and work. And it’s also undergoing constant change.
From this starting point, we set off all over Scotland.
Our journey took us to the tiny island of Mousa on Shetland to explore the wonderfully Scottish enigma of the broch – huge, round stone structures, built for reasons that we still don’t fully understand.
And next we were off to another island – Canna – in search of one of our most mysterious Christian sites. It also just so happened to be one of our most inaccessible: found at the bottom of a section of massive cliffs, several kilometres from the end of the nearest road.
Our only option was to abseil down. What waited at the foot of the cliffs – known as ‘Sgorr nam Ban-naomha’, the ‘scree of the holy women’ – was a remarkable monastic site, first established some 1,500 years ago.
Abseiling down ‘The Scree of the Holy Women’ to a 1,500-year-old Christian site on the Isle of Canna (Photo: BBC)
From herring harbours to art deco swimming pools
From these ancient remains we moved on to more modern-day stories. Just south of Wick, we used our drone to capture a spectacular view of the Whaligoe Steps. Here a series of three-hundred-and-sixty-five stone steps lead up the side of a sheer cliff face.
Women known as ‘herring girls’ used to haul the catch from a tiny harbour some 250 feet up to the village at the top. While the fish have gone, this site remains – an enduring and poignant monument to the communities who worked the herring.
We travelled on to Britain’s oldest business, Aberdeen harbour, and then further north, to a tiny inlet west of Macduff. Here, at a place called Tarlair, we explored the ruins of a seemingly unlikely feature of the Scottish coastline: an outdoor swimming pool, known as a ‘lido’.
For the government of the 1930s, the lidos were all about public health – promoting physical and mental excellence. But for others it was less about rigorous exercise and more about simple pleasure. Lidos were where you went to see and be seen.
The ruins of Tarlair Lido (Photo: BBC)
Some lidos were huge – Stonehaven had seats for 3,000 people; Portobello could hold a staggering 6,000. They became icons of municipal pride, with every town vying to build the biggest and brightest. But by the latter half of the twentieth century, the fad was over. Why swim in the North Sea when you could fly to the Mediterranean?
From above you still can spot the traces of many of the abandoned pools – their ruins fading back into the cliffs and the rocks. They add yet another – rather unexpected – layer to the long history of our coastline.
An ever-changing landscape
Our final stop was a distinctive structure set on a peninsula jutting out into the Moray Firth: Fort George. It was engineered to be impregnable – built as a Highland base for the forces of George II in the years after Bonnie Prince Charlie’s failed rebellion. But there was one foe its designers didn’t count on. The sea…
Fort George captured by drone in the morning sunlight (Photo: BBC)
Fort George is right on the firing line when it comes to coastal erosion, as HES climate scientist David Harkin explained.
“Anecdotal evidence from people who work round the site suggests that we are losing up to a metre of ground in successive winter storms” David told us. “We are incredibly lucky to have such a rich and diverse historic environment. People love coming to sites like this. If they realise that the impact of climate change might mean that they lose them – then that’s what they need to inspire them to take action.”
James Crawford and HES Climate Scientist David Harkin, on the north shoreline of Fort George (Photo: BBC)
A coastline that never stops changing
Our experience of making this episode showed us that you can take almost any beach, bay, dune or cliff-side and you’ll find the traces of us, of people. Our shorelines have stood for survival, threat, opportunity and adventure over many thousands of years.
Yet a day doesn’t go by without the inevitable shift of this physical border – from the coming and going of the tides, to rising sea-levels and the never-ending process of erosion.
What we see when we look down on our coast from above is a landscape rich in history and memory. But it is also a landscape that never stops changing. At once enduringly vibrant – and dangerously fragile.
Series Two of Scotland from the Sky takes-off at 9pm on BBC One Scotland on 17 April.
James Crawford has moved on to pastures new, but until 2019 he was our Publishing Manager. He has researched Scotland’s National Collection of Aerial Photography and has written a number of books on it, including Above Scotland, Scotland's Landscapes, and Aerofilms: A History of Britain from Above.
He is also the author of Fallen Glory: The Lives and Deaths of the World’s Greatest Lost Buildings, shortlisted for the 2016 Saltire Non-Fiction Book of the Year Award, and is Chair of the Board of Publishing Scotland. Scotland from the Sky is his first series for the BBC as writer and presenter.
View all posts by James Crawford